Food Science · Nutrition

Raw vs Pasteurised Milk: What's Actually Different?

The short answer

Pasteurised milk has been heated, most often to 72C for 15 seconds, to kill the bacteria and viruses that raw milk can carry. That is the main difference. Nutritionally the two are very close: calcium, protein and most vitamins are unchanged, a few B vitamins drop slightly, and the lactose is identical. Raw milk is not legally sold for drinking anywhere in Australia, and in the US it depends on the state.

The difference between raw and pasteurised milk is a brief heat step that kills germs and leaves the nutrition almost untouched. Here is what pasteurisation does, what it changes and does not change, and where you stand legally in Australia and the US.

What does pasteurisation actually do to milk?

Pasteurisation is a heat treatment designed to kill the disease-causing microbes that can be present in milk straight from the cow. The two standard methods are:

  • High temperature, short time (HTST): 72C for 15 seconds, then rapid cooling. This is how most supermarket milk is treated.
  • Low temperature, long time (LTLT) or batch: 63C for 30 minutes.

FSANZ describes those two combinations as the internationally recognised minimums (FSANZ). Canada’s rules add that products with 10% or more fat, or added sugar, go to 75C for 15 seconds, because fat and sugar protect bacteria a little (CFIA). UHT milk, the long-life kind, is a separate process at much higher temperatures that sterilises rather than pasteurises.

Those time and temperature combinations were worked out to kill the hardiest common pathogens with a safety margin: Campylobacter, Salmonella, Listeria, the dangerous E. coli strains, Brucella and Coxiella. Since 2024 we also know they inactivate H5N1 bird flu. FDA testing that simulated commercial processing found the usual pasteurisation times and temperatures effective against the virus, including milk spiked with far more virus than any infected cow produces (Scripps News, FDA).

Pasteurisation is not sterilisation. Some harmless bacteria survive, which is why pasteurised milk still goes off in the fridge after a week or two.

Does pasteurised milk lose nutrients?

Very little. The FDA’s summary is that numerous studies have found pasteurisation has minimal impact on milk’s nutritional quality (FDA). A 2025 review of the heat-treatment literature found calcium and phosphorus essentially unaffected, with small differences in thiamine (B1) and pyridoxine (B6) between raw and pasteurised milk (PubMed Central). Vitamin C falls too, but milk was never a meaningful source of it; a glass of raw milk has a fraction of the vitamin C in a slice of capsicum.

The CDC puts the practical conclusion this way: most of the nutritional benefits of drinking milk are available from pasteurised milk without the risk of illness (CDC).

Raw milkPasteurised milk
Heat treatmentNone72C for 15 s, or 63C for 30 min
PathogensWhatever was in the cow, the udder, the equipment or the airKilled to a safety margin, including H5N1
Protein, fat, calcium, phosphorusPresentUnchanged
Thiamine, B6, vitamin CPresentSlightly lower
LactosePresentUnchanged
Lactase enzymeNone (milk does not contain it)None
Probiotic bacteriaNot in a useful sense; raw milk bacteria are not probiotic strainsNone (added separately in yoghurt and kefir)
Shelf life, refrigeratedA few daysOne to two weeks
Legal to sell for drinking in AustraliaNoYes

Not ready for a trial? Join the free MindShift Mentors newsletter instead.

No credit card required. Then $29.95 AUD a month or $299 AUD a year. Results vary. Designed to work alongside professional care, not replace it.

Does raw milk have enzymes or good bacteria that pasteurised milk lacks?

This is the most common argument for raw milk and it does not hold up.

Lactose and lactase. Lactose intolerance happens because the body does not make enough lactase, the enzyme that digests lactose. Raw milk advocates say pasteurisation destroys the lactase in milk. The FDA points out that milk has no lactase to begin with: there is no indigenous lactase in milk, raw or pasteurised, and the lactose content does not change with heating (FDA). Raw milk will trigger lactose intolerance exactly as pasteurised milk does.

Probiotics. The bacteria naturally present in raw milk are environmental bacteria from the animal and the dairy. They are not the characterised strains used in probiotic foods, and some of them are the pathogens the heat step is there to kill. If you want probiotics, yoghurt or kefir made from pasteurised milk with added cultures is the straightforward route; we explain how those cultures work in is lactic acid starter culture dairy?

Enzymes. Heat does inactivate milk’s own enzymes, which is in fact how pasteurisation is checked: a test for alkaline phosphatase, an enzyme that is destroyed at just above pasteurisation temperature, confirms the milk reached the right heat. Those enzymes are there for the calf’s digestion and milk chemistry, not for yours; your own digestive enzymes do the work either way.

Not for drinking. Standard 4.2.4 of the Food Standards Code requires milk sold for human consumption to be pasteurised or given an equivalent treatment, and FSANZ concluded that the risks from raw drinking milk were too great to consider changing that (FSANZ). The one food exception is some raw milk cheeses, permitted since 2014 under strict controls over how the cheese is made and aged (Better Health Channel). Some states also allow raw goat’s milk under their dairy schemes with a warning label.

For years the workaround was “bath milk”: raw milk sold as a cosmetic, labelled not for human consumption, that everyone understood was being drunk. That ended in Victoria after a three-year-old boy died in October 2014 of haemolytic uraemic syndrome, a kidney complication of E. coli infection, with other children ill in the same cluster. The coroner later found raw milk the probable cause (Food Safety News). From 1 January 2015 Victoria required any bath milk to be either pasteurised or dosed with a bittering agent to make it undrinkable (Food Safety News). Most producers switched to pasteurising.

It depends where you are. Federal law bans raw milk from crossing state lines for sale, and each state sets its own rules inside its borders. A mid-2025 count found 18 states prohibiting sales outright and 32 allowing them under some conditions (National Agricultural Law Center); about a dozen allow sale in retail shops, mostly in the West, with the rest limited to on-farm sales or cow-share arrangements (CSG Midwest). Several states loosened their laws in 2025, so check your own state’s agriculture department for the current position.

The law matters because it tracks the illness data. A CDC and FDA review of 1998 to 2018 found 78% of single-state raw milk outbreaks occurred in states where sale was allowed, and about three times as many outbreaks in jurisdictions permitting retail sale as in those prohibiting it (Epidemiology and Infection).

Who should never drink raw milk?

Anyone can get sick from raw milk, but the CDC singles out four groups for whom the consequences are most likely to be severe: children under five, pregnant women, adults over 65, and anyone with a weakened immune system (CDC). Pregnancy is a particular concern because of Listeria, which can cause miscarriage and stillbirth; a 2016 multistate listeriosis outbreak was traced to one raw milk producer (CDC). In the 2013 to 2018 US data, 48% of raw milk illnesses were in people aged 19 or under.

If a claim about raw milk sounds alarming rather than microbiological, there is a good chance it is the one we checked in is there vaccine in raw milk?

Common questions

What temperature is milk pasteurised at?

Most commonly 72C for 15 seconds, called HTST, followed by rapid cooling. The older batch method is 63C for 30 minutes. Both are recognised minimums under Australian, Canadian and US rules.

Does pasteurisation destroy nutrients in milk?

Only slightly. Protein, fat, calcium and phosphorus are unchanged, and a few vitamins such as thiamine, B6 and C fall a little. The FDA and CDC both describe the nutritional effect as minimal.

Is raw milk easier to digest for lactose intolerance?

No. Milk contains no lactase enzyme, raw or pasteurised, and the lactose content is the same. Lactose intolerance is about your body’s enzyme supply, not the milk’s.

Raw cow’s milk cannot be sold for drinking in any Australian state or territory. Some raw milk cheeses are permitted under strict rules, and some states allow raw goat’s milk with a warning label. Victoria’s bath milk loophole closed in 2015.

Does pasteurisation kill bird flu in milk?

Yes. FDA testing in 2024 found standard pasteurisation inactivated H5N1, including in milk spiked with high levels of virus. Infectious virus has been found in raw milk from infected herds and in retail raw milk in California.

How is pasteurised milk different from UHT milk?

Pasteurised milk is heated briefly to kill pathogens and still needs refrigeration. UHT or long-life milk is heated to a much higher temperature for a few seconds, which sterilises it so it keeps for months unopened at room temperature.

The bottom line

Pasteurisation is 15 seconds at 72C. It kills the bacteria and viruses that raw milk can carry, costs almost nothing nutritionally, and does not touch the lactose. Raw milk has no enzymes or probiotics that help you digest it. In Australia raw drinking milk is off the table by law, and the Victorian bath milk case is the reason.

Keep reading: Food Science · Is there vaccine in raw milk? · Is goat’s cheese and milk paleo? · Does coconut milk have lactose?

Sources

  1. Scientific Evaluation of Pasteurisation for Pathogen Reduction in Milk and Milk Products, Food Standards Australia New Zealand
  2. Dairy processing: High temperature short time (HTST) pasteurization systems, Canadian Food Inspection Agency
  3. Effect of Heat Pasteurization and Sterilization on Milk Safety, Composition, Sensory Properties, and Nutritional Quality, PubMed Central
  4. Raw Milk Misconceptions and the Danger of Raw Milk Consumption, US Food and Drug Administration
  5. Raw Milk Questions and Answers, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
  6. Raw drinking milk, Food Standards Australia New Zealand
  7. Raw (unpasteurised) milk, Better Health Channel, Victoria
  8. Coroner rules raw milk caused boy's death, Food Safety News
  9. Australian state restricts raw 'bath milk' sales in wake of boy's death, Food Safety News
  10. Food Law in the States: 2025 Update, National Agricultural Law Center
  11. States set the rules on intrastate sales of raw milk, Council of State Governments Midwest
  12. Map of State Laws on the Sale of Unpasteurized Cow's Milk, 2012 to 2019, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
  13. Foodborne illness outbreaks linked to unpasteurised milk and relationship to changes in state laws, United States, 1998 to 2018, Epidemiology and Infection (CDC and FDA authors)
  14. Multistate Outbreak of Listeriosis Linked to Raw Milk Produced by Miller's Organic Farm in Pennsylvania, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
  15. Pasteurization completely inactivates bird flu from raw milk, FDA says, Scripps News
  16. Investigation of Avian Influenza A (H5N1) Virus in Dairy Cattle, US Food and Drug Administration

Not ready for a trial? Join the free MindShift Mentors newsletter instead.

No credit card required. Then $29.95 AUD a month or $299 AUD a year. Results vary. Designed to work alongside professional care, not replace it.